Cap rate is one of the first terms anyone learns in commercial real estate, and one of the most misunderstood. You will see it in broker listings, offering summaries, and market reports, often presented as if it tells you everything about a deal. It does not. But it does tell you something useful, as long as you know what goes into it and what it leaves out.
This guide explains what a cap rate is, how it is calculated, what it does and does not tell a passive investor, and why we think the number a building produces matters more than the number a market assigns to it.
What a cap rate is
A capitalization rate, or cap rate, is a simple ratio:
Cap rate = net operating income ÷ property value (or purchase price)
Net operating income, or NOI, is the property's income after operating expenses but before debt payments and income taxes. The cap rate expresses that income as a percentage of what the property is worth or what someone is paying for it.
Here is a simple illustration with round numbers chosen only to make the math easy. It is not a market figure or an actual deal. If a building produces $500,000 of NOI and sells for $10 million, the cap rate is 5 percent. If the same NOI were bought for $8 million, the cap rate would be 6.25 percent.
You can also flip the formula around: value = NOI ÷ cap rate. That version explains why cap rates matter so much to owners. At any given cap rate, higher NOI means higher value.
What goes into NOI, and what does not
Because the cap rate is only as good as the NOI behind it, it pays to know what NOI includes.
Included in NOI:
Rental income and other property income, such as laundry, parking, storage, or utility reimbursements, less vacancy and credit loss.
Operating expenses such as property management, repairs and maintenance, utilities paid by the owner, property taxes, insurance, payroll, and administrative costs.
Not included in NOI:
Mortgage payments, both principal and interest.
Major capital expenditures, such as a new roof or full unit renovations, which are usually tracked separately.
Depreciation and income taxes.
Because NOI leaves out debt, the cap rate describes the property, not the financing. Two buyers using very different loans would see the same cap rate on the same building at the same price.
Going-in cap rates, pro forma cap rates, and why the difference matters
When you read an offering or a broker listing, check which NOI the cap rate is based on.
A trailing or in-place cap rate uses what the property has actually produced, usually over the last twelve months.
A pro forma cap rate uses what someone projects the property will produce after changes, such as higher rents or lower expenses.
Both can be legitimate, but they answer different questions. A trailing number tells you what you are buying today. A pro forma number tells you what someone hopes to achieve. Mixing them up, or presenting a pro forma figure as if it were current, can make a deal look much better than it is.
What cap rates tell you
Used carefully, cap rates are a helpful shorthand.
They let you compare similar properties. Two comparable apartment buildings in the same area can be compared on price relative to income.
They reflect how the market views risk and growth. Buyers generally accept lower cap rates for properties and locations they see as safer or more likely to grow, and they ask for higher cap rates where they see more risk.
They connect income to value. Because value equals NOI divided by the cap rate, every dollar of NOI an owner adds is multiplied in the property's value.
What cap rates do not tell you
A cap rate is a snapshot, and it leaves out a lot.
It ignores financing. The cap rate says nothing about the loan, the interest rate, or whether the property's income covers its debt payments.
It ignores capital needs. An older building with a deferred roof replacement and a newer building with no major needs can show the same cap rate.
It is not a return. A cap rate is not the return an investor should expect. Investor returns depend on financing, capital spending, operations, fees, the length of the hold, and the eventual sale.
It can be based on the wrong NOI. If expenses are understated, or if the income includes rents that have not actually been achieved, the cap rate will be misleading.
How market cap rates move, and why we do not bet on it
Market cap rates change over time. When interest rates and investor demand shift, buyers may pay more or less for the same income. A drop in market cap rates, often called cap rate compression, raises property values without any change in how the building performs. A rise, called expansion, does the opposite.
Some investment plans quietly rely on compression. They assume a buyer in a few years will pay a lower cap rate than the sponsor paid today. When that happens, it can make results look excellent. When it does not, the plan can come up short even if the building was run well.
We do not underwrite that way. In our underwriting, a deal needs no cap-rate compression, no rate cuts, and no rent spike to work. Year-one income is anchored to trailing financials, not to a broker pro forma. If the market later rewards our properties with a lower cap rate, that is a bonus we did not plan around.
Operations, not cap rates
If value equals NOI divided by the cap rate, there are two ways to grow it: hope the market lowers the cap rate, or raise the NOI. We focus on the second, because it is the one we control.
We buy mismanaged, not distressed, workforce housing: 30 to 100 unit communities built in the 1960s to 1990s in Pierce and Snohomish Counties. These buildings often have rents below market, expenses that have gone unchecked, and units that have fallen behind. Our work is to close the gap on rents gradually through turnover and renewals, rebid vendors and restructure the operating cost base, and run screening, collections, and maintenance to one standard. Each of those steps shows up in NOI, and NOI is what the cap rate is applied to.
You can read more about where we buy and why in our post on what workforce housing is, and about how we operate on our strategy page.
Questions to ask about a cap rate in any offering
Is this cap rate based on trailing income or projected income?
What expenses are included in NOI, and do they include a full property management cost?
Are property taxes and insurance shown at realistic go-forward levels, not simply what the seller happened to pay?
What capital needs does the building have that are not reflected in NOI?
Does the plan assume a lower cap rate at sale than at purchase?
About Veritas
We have been investing in Washington multifamily for sixteen years. Since 2010 we have closed 21 deals and acquired 468 units, and we manage about $85 million in assets, with no realized losses on any deal.
Talk it through with us
If you are looking at an offering and want to understand what its cap rate does and does not tell you, we would be glad to walk through it with you. Book a Discovery Call and bring the numbers.
This website is for informational purposes only. It is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, securities. Any offering is made only through official offering documents, and only to investors who meet the requirements of that offering. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Investing in real estate involves risk, including the possible loss of capital.

